Saturday, June 16, 2007


Low Cost Wireless Technologies for Internet Access
I. Introduction

Information and communications have become increasingly fundamental for social and economic development. Access to basic infrastructure has become a key to increase the flow of information and improve communications. Policy makers and regulators need to rethink definition of universal service to take into consideration user needs for information and communications and changes in technologies. Universal access should not be defined simply from access to telecommunications. It should cover the delivery of education, healthcare, business and global information resources through the Internet.
Providing access to information and communications particularly to the Internet requires two complementary network infrastructure components: a backhaul connection to bring an Internet connection to the town or region, and a distribution mechanism to make the backhaul connection available to individual users. Satellite technology is the prime mechanism for getting backhaul Internet connectivity to many African countries; although fiber optics and DSL connections are becoming increasingly available particularly in most large urban areas. However, for the majority of rural areas, satellite and terrestrial wireless broadband links are often the only choice for backhaul connectivity and for distribution of access to homes. Rural areas require communication systems that are low cost in areas where population density is low, easy to install, operate and maintain systems. Most African villages do not have the infrastructure that facilitates the construction of backhaul cables including roads, railroads and pipelines.
Terrestrial Wireless and satellite technologies have shown considerable potential for brining connectivity to remote parts of Africa. The lack of affordable access to phone and Internet connectivity for the sparsely scattered majority in Africa, who are not close to even small urban centers, has been a problem because, it is now well-established, the productivity of poor households must increase if they are to rise out of poverty. Increasing productivity is difficult without timely access to information, the ability to network and learn from others, or the ability to interact with markets, governments, and other resources. Economic growth on the other hand cannot be achieved without improving the efficiency of institutions, markets and businesses through ongoing learning.
Low cost VSAT technologies and their wireless extension such as WiFi and WiMaX have a substantial role in increasing access to these opportunities in Africa. VSATs are easy and quick to set up and maintain, distance insensitive and promote efficient spectrum use. WiFi andWiMaX technologies offer the advantage of lowering the cost of upgrading and expanding backbone data networks in underserved areas with point- to- point wireless transmissions available up to 50 Kms and inexpensive last mile distribution or neighborhood networks. As the technology evolves wireless has become a very effective, low cost “last mile” solution for those who need universal access the most.
II. Low cost Internet Connectivity Technologies

From Internet access point of view, there are a number of technologies such as mobile communication systems, bluetooth, wireless local loop, LMDS and MMDS, mesh networks, WiMax and copper wire including power line that provide low cost access to networks. Wired network technologies such as dialup, ISDN, Digital Subscriber Lines, leased lines and fiber offer better connectivity to the Internet. However, these have disadvantages. The most obvious is that the cost of building the exchanges and laying fiber cable or cooper is high. There is also high probability of bad quality copper resulting in bad data lines. In contrast, although they cannot offer bandwidth comparable to wired connections such as fiber, wireless technologies can be easily deployed in areas where teledensity is low. Table 1. lists the most widely used wireless technologies for broadband Internet Access.

Table 1. Major wireless technologies for expansion of Internet Access

Technology
Description
Strength
Weaknesses
VSAT
Small satellite terminal that can be used for one-way and/or two-way interactive communications via satellite
Can be installed virtually anywhere
High bandwidth available

High initial costs
Difficult installation

Wireless Local Loop
Use of wireless radio signals to provide either voice or both voice and data services to fixed-point subscribers (primarily residential) who are not currently served by landlines. Broadband application examples include CoreDECT

Infrastructure built and maintained by telco normally for voice
Deployment quick and easy Reasonable data rates
Inexpensive,
proven in rural
settings
Good range
Costs do not scale well
Limited bandwidth Technology is somewhat immature
Proprietary systems
Requires licenses
MMDS/LMDS
MMDS ‘is generally used to refer to fixed microwave data
distribution systems below about 10 GHz. LMDS is generally used to refer to microwave data distribution
systems operating above 10 GHz, generally in the range 24-32 GHz (10 mm wavelength) making them only useful for line-of sight
(LOS) communications.

Wide area coverage (20-40 Kms)
Higher data rates

Should be carefully engineered
over a line of sight and utilise external antennas carefully aimed
and set up.



WiFi
WiFi (802.11x) are a relatively mature set of IEEE standards for wireless networking of a Local Area Network (LAN)


Ideal for distribution within a small geographic area (like a village)
Relatively low-cost
No communications infrastructure required
Can use special hardware to extend range Mature technology

Limited range (200 meters) for standard hardware
Crossing long distances requires special hardware at higher cost

WiMAX
WiMAX (802.16x) defines family of wireless networking standards defines a set of solutions for Metropolitan Area Networks (MAN) with a range of up to 50 kilometres


High data rates (up to 70 Mbps)
Covers distances up to 30 kilometers
Easy to provision new service


Not yet widely available
Requires additional backhaul to feed wireless network
Uses licensed and unlicensed band, no mobility

Bluetooth
Bluetooth is an advanced protocol for the transmission of data at a rate of about 1.5 Mbps between portable devices in a secure
and reliable manner.
Indoor or personal use
Does not require licensing
Limited distance
Lower data rate
Limited to commercial application
3G
3G stands for third generation mobile phone system which
provides both voice and broadband data access. These include CDMA2000, W-CDMA, UMTS, GPRS and EDGE. GPRS and EDGE are actually 2.5G technologies because they build upon existing 2G (second generation) GSM infrastructure.
Mobile extension
Good mobile data rates

The frequency bands (800, 900, 1800 and 2500 MHz need licensing
Uptake has been limited
Expensive infrastructure
Mesh Networks
Mesh networks are wireless networks composed of autonomous nodes that are able to self-organize. Each node is a wireless (often 802.11-based) radio unit that contains software that enables it to act as a mini-router. By creating a multi-hop network that spans many nodes, a mesh network can effectively extend the range of a traditional 802.11 network.

Extends the range of wireless technologies
Small scale-up increment
May be used to create a more robust distribution network

Relatively immature technology
Must be combined with other technologies


Adapted from, George Conard, Internet Connectivity Technologies, 2004

In the areas where broadband access cannot be achieved through wired networks, satellites networks are very attractive to provide communications. In effect, satellite technology is often the only choice to provide the main channel to global Internet. Distribution of access to villages several kilometres apart generally requires wireless solutions. Wireless technologies provide a significant life-time cost benefits in rural areas in case where the deployment of cable is uneconomic. They provide an easy and speedy installation in harsh terrain and extremely remote areas. With smaller investment increments and avoidance of copper cable theft, wireless technologies allow economic deployment. They provide lower maintenance cost and greater network flexibility. The following section summarizes some of the low cost technologies used for backhaul connections and Internet distribution.
1. VSAT
VSAT is a small-sized telecommunications earth station that transmits and receives via satellite. The terminal size is often 1.2 to 2.4 meter in diameter. The VSAT comprises of two modules - an outdoor unit and an indoor unit. The outdoor unit is generally ground or even wall mounted and the indoor unit which is the size of a desktop computer is normally located near existing computer equipment in an office. The outdoor unit consists of an Antenna and Radio Frequency Transceiver (RFT). The term "hub" is typically used to describe networks that require one of the earth stations in the network to manage and control the services provided.
VSATs are becoming increasingly popular, because they provide flexible communications platform that can be installed quickly and cost effectively to provide telecoms solutions for consumers, governments and corporations. VSAT networks offer value-added satellite-based services capable of supporting the Internet, data, LAN, voice/fax communications, and can provide powerful, dependable, private and public network communications solutions. They can be used for a wide variety of telecommunications applications, including corporate networks, Internet service provision, rural telecoms, distance learning, telemedicine, cybercafes, banking, oil and gas exploration, manufacturing, government agencies and departments and much more. The broadcast nature of satellites allows for the simultaneous delivery of information to wide geographic areas without regard to terrestrial infrastructure or geographic barriers.
Charges for terrestrial services are nearly always distance-dependent, while VSAT connections cost the same whether sites are one or 1000 Km apart. VSATs are capable of sending and receiving all sorts of video, data and audio content at the same high speed regardless of their distance from terrestrial switching offices and infrastructure
Technology is also changing rapidly to make VSATe access to the Internet more affordable. Some of the recent developments have been in the area of improved bandwidth efficiency by combining satellite coding schemes and modulation systems with Internet protocols, which have resulted in a new family of IP-based VSAT systems (IP-VSAT). These are generally based on hybrid network topologies and have been designed to deliver a variety of communications services on a single platform based on direct connectivity to LANs, with voice services delivered via VoIP. IP over Digital Video Broadcasting (DVB) has become the de facto standard for broadband communications via satellite, and such systems clearly demonstrate their greatest cost-effectiveness by matching the asymmetric nature of Internet traffic. Satellite services can provide 35-45 Mbps for backbone connections, with significantly greater data rates available for key business applications, e.g. videoconferencing. Multicasting speeds routinely reach 2-3 Mbps and delivery of Internet to consumers can be achieved at 400 Kbps or more.
Further, new standards are being introduced, such as DVB Return Channel via Satellite (DVB-RCS), which combines with TCP/IP to provide fully-integrated high-speed services. The success of mobile standard showed that it is possible to create an open standard to which many suppliers could build equipment and thereby create higher economies of scale and cost reductions. The same dynamic has now begun with the development of the DVB-RCS standard, which was developed by the same organization that developed GSM: The European Telecommunications Standards Institute (ETSI). For the first time, inter-operability between VSAT equipment from numerous suppliers is possible, although manufacturers have only recently started to produce systems based on these standards.
There are 3 major signal bands available on the VSAT system. They are the C-band (4-6 GHz), KU-band (10-20 GHz) and the Ka- band (20-30 GHz). The C-Band is the lowest frequency signal based transponder, which exhibits reliable capability to withstand weather interference. It also allows the largest bandwidth upgradability. The Ku band is subject to weather change interference. A prolonged rain or cloudy weather sometimes affects transmission. Typically, interactive Ku-band antenna sizes range from 75 centimetres to 1.8 metres and C-band from 1.8 metres to 2.4 metres.
The key advantage of a VSAT earth station, versus a typical terrestrial network connection, is that the reach of buried cable does not limit VSATs. Satellite is the only telephony and broadband wide-area network technology that is available everywhere - in even the most remote urban and rural areas, rain forests or concrete jungles, anywhere in the world. A VSAT earth station can be placed anywhere - as long as it has an unobstructed view of the satellite. Figure 1. shows Ku –band beam coverage of west Africa.Relocating and adding network sites is much simpler and cheaper with a satellite network than with most terrestrial technologies. VSAT networks are highly scalable, i.e. it provides the ability to scale according to the customer's requirements with low incremental cost. This is especially important as businesses grow over time.A VSAT network can support thousands of VSAT remotes. Hence, a customer may start with Data services (internet browsing & e-mail) and then adding more bandwidth can be done over time by a simple reconfiguration at the Network Operating Center. In addition customers are able to add voice capabilities or video applications when the need arises.
VSATs have some disadvantages when compared to competing technologies including lack of adequate satellite coverage in some parts of the world, limitations in service quality particularly in signal delay. The signal transmitted from a VSAT terminal to another terminal takes about 250 milliseconds. There is also limited skills base for designing, installing and maintaining sophisticated satellite communication systems. However, VSAT offer quick, easily and cheap connectivity in rural areas, where other competing technologies do not exist.

2. WiFi – 802.11x Wireless

Most distribution networks are becoming increasingly dependent on 802.11x wireless LAN standard. These standards often dubbed by the industry as Wireless Fidelity (WiFi) allow communications within relatively small area. Wireless Local Area Networks (WLANs) were originally employed to allow network elements to roam in manufacturing and warehouse facilities, providing a cost savings alternative or complement to wired networks.
WLANs have now become ubiquitous. They are usually centred on a base station or access point, which creates “last mile” connectivity. The service area of the access point (AP) is known as a “hotspot”. An 802.11x-based wireless network consists at least one access point (AP) and several client devices. The access point is wired to a standard Ethernet-based LAN. When client devices connect to the AP, they behave as though they were physically connected to the network. 802.11b access points can also operate in a peer-to-peer mode. Typical range for an 802.11b-based network is about 200 meters with full line-of-sight. Indoor range is significantly lower.
A typical use of WiFi would be to place the Access Point strategically around an office, each connected to the wired Internet and thus allow any Pc or other data terminal in the area to get access to the network. The Access Points can be deployed privately, for example employees can use them or they may be deployed publicly in common places such as the airports and coffee shops where users may use them for fee or free.
The original 802.11 standard for WLAN technologies was published in 1999 and provides for data rates up to 2 Mbps at 2.4 GHz, using either Frequency hopping Spread Spectrum (FHSS) or Direct Sequence Spread Spectrum (DSSS). Since then many task groups have been formed to create supplements and enhancements to the original standard. At present there are task groups “a” through “k”, which are working on various methods to standardize improvements to the 802.11 standard. WiFis are widely deployed within Industrial Scientific and Medical (ISM) bands of 2400 – 2500 MHz (2.4 GHz) and 5725 – 5875 MHz (5.8 GHz ISM). The hardware is low cost and the 802.11x standard is becoming ubiquitous for short- range local area networks.
WiFi also offer standard compliance to 802.11x and simple configuration and operation but limited in its range (200 meters). Crossing long distances requires special hardware at higher cost
3. Bluetooth
Bluetooth is an IEEE 802.15.1 standard for the transmission of data at a rate of about 1.5 Mbps between portable devices in a secure and reliable manner. It uses unlicensed spectrum at 2.4 GHz over ranges of 0-10 metres. Bluetooth replaces short wire connections (of a few metres) with wireless connections; its short range and very low power means that it cannot be a last mile broadband communications Service. It is generally driven by mobile phone manufacturers who want lower-powered implementations of greater flexibility and simplicity and with a definite need to ensure the privacy of all those who use it. Bluetooth has limited regulatory implications since it specifies a wireless personal access network limited to 0-10m.
4. WiMax
WiMax stands for Worldwide Interoperability for Microwave Access and defines radio access technology based on the family of IEEE 802.16 standards. The 802.16x IEEE standards define wireless networking protocols geared toward “metropolitan” area networks with a range of about 50 kilometers. 802.16 starts from the premise of delivering broadband data to fixed points. The standards are in varying stages of development; 802.16a was ratified in January 2003 and holds a lot of promise for rural and developing world scenarios with non-line-of-sight connectivity.
For example, villages within 30-50 Kms from major cities can attain broadband connectivity through Wimax with a maximum throughput of 60 megabytes per second (Mbps) in a 20-MHz channel, as compared to 25 useful Mbps under standards 802.11 a or g. The quality of service of WiMax is also superior. It guarantees a good level for the services with limited latency delays, which proves to be essential, for example, in transmitting Voice over IP.
Wimax is still at an early stage of development. It requires additional connection to the Internet to feed into wireless networks.
5. Mesh Networks
Mesh networks are wireless networks composed of autonomous nodes that are able to self-organize. Each node is a wireless (often WiFi) and contains software that enables it to act as a mini-router. By creating a multi-hop network that spans many nodes, a mesh network can effectively extend the range of a traditional WiFi network. Mesh networks are a highly innovative extension of wireless networking technology.
Many communities, in Africa do not have broadband Internet access. Using mesh networks, these communities can share a single broadband connection broadly among community members. A village that has access to a reasonable backhaul connection to the Internet can start small – with a single node – and then add nodes as demand increases throughout the village and as scaling up the project becomes financially viable.
Connections between nodes are often made on-demand and packets are routed across the network either using predetermined routing tables (proactive routing) or using routes generated on demand by the network (reactive routing). Properly configured mesh networks should be self-healing – if a node goes down, the remaining nodes in the network can reconfigure their routes to work around the failure.
Although the topology is self-healing, it adds latency as the network grows. This means there should be a tradeoff between network connectivity (coverage), delay requirements, security, network capacity, power and budget. Besides, most of the current ad hoc networks are experimental and require substantial innovation and maturity.
6. Wireless Local Loop
Wireless Local Loop refers to the use of wireless radio signals to provide either voice or both voice and data services to fixed-point subscribers (primarily residential) who are not currently served by landlines. The basic WLL implementation involves setting up a number of microcells – transmitters that can send and receive data – that connect back to a wired connectivity source such as a phone center or broadband access point. Individual subscribers receive wireless devices to connect to their computer that access the network via the WLL microcells. In some cases, telcos sell handset devices that have the wireless antenna built into them and are similar in operation to a standard wired telephone handset.
CorDECT system invented by the Indian Institute of Technology in Chennai is a typical broadband implementation of Wireless Local Loop to provide universal access. The corDECT system provides simultaneous toll-quality circuit-switched voice services along with packet data transmission at 35-70 Kbits/second. The design philosophy focused on improving Internet connectivity in rural areas while at the same time providing voice connectivity. Operational costs are reduced by de-multiplexing the voice and data at the system interface unit – data can then be routed directly to the Internet service provider without going through the Public Switched Telephone Network. Possible distance between the subscribers and base station is about 10 Kms but repeaters can be used to extend the distance further. Although the deployment of WLL is quick and easy, the bandwidth is low (35-70 Kbits/sec). So far the technology is proprietary making interoperability with other technologies rather difficult.
7. 3G Cellular Networks
3G stands for third generation mobile phone system which provides both voice and broadband data access. These include CDMA2000, W-CDMA, UMTS, GPRS and EDGE. GPRS and EDGE are actually 2.5G technologies because they build upon existing 2G (second generation) GSM infrastructure. The 3G cellular system start with the premise pf delivering high quality mobile data services in low-band and mid-band range. The infrastructure is optimised for high mobility including high-speed handoff. 2.5G only offered on lower throughput rates (50 – 60 Kbps) in South Africa and is relatively expensive. GPRS is in the process of being deployed in Egypt, Morocco, Nigeria, Senegal, Tunisia, whereas CDMA2000-based Internet services are now being deployed in Nigeria - by Mobile Telecommunications Service (MTS), Starcomms and Reliance Telecom. Inmarsat RBGAN is being positioned as a GPRS equivalent, at up to 144 Kbps, however it is more expensive than other wireless alternatives. However 3G cellular networks are not available in Africa as up take of the technology was too slow compared to the enthusiasm.
III. Conclusion
The brief description above showed that there are various technologies that promise the provision of access to the Internet cheaply. However, the cost of the service does not necessarily depend on the technology. The right choice for a particular project will depend on bandwidth requirements, the project budget, and availability of internet access from ISPs or telecoms in the region.
It was also argued that, in the absence of wired infrastructure, wireless technologies can be used more effectively to provide connectivity. Fast declining costs make wireless technologies more affordable. Within certain performance parameters, wireless technologies such as WiFi are inexpensive. Wireless technologies are also increasingly becoming embedded into intelligent devices such as mobile phones and notebooks. It is now possible to shift from a local WiFi connection with voice over IP to a regular cellular service. Wireless technologies are increasingly being optimised to harness the spectrum effectively and reduce interference.
More importantly, new development in wireless technologies showed that multiple licensed users can operate overlapping network changing the traditional paradigm of top-down services. These networks are becoming revolutionary in the sense that they allow users to build their networks from bottom-up. Each entrepreneur can easily provide services to local community by purchasing basic radio equipment and building the necessary skills for negotiating with other networks and troubleshooting the network. Combined with backhaul connection via VSATs, the model has become increasingly attractive, inexpensive, responds to the local needs, can grow organically and is fully scalable. By using a box with pre-installed wireless mesh software and standard wireless protocol users can establish networks and link that to an Internet backbone using existing ISP or directly via VSAT. Some countries like South Africa have already taken a step to encourage this bottom-up rural service provision model by licensing to small and medium enterprises to establish value –added services in rural areas.

It is important to note that wireless services have disadvantages. They will never be as high performance as fiber deployment. Therefore it is best to see wireless network as complementing rather than replacing wired networks. Radio technology standards are still very much in development. The performance of wireless technologies is till limited, but improving. Regulators should remain well informed of the development in order to promote universal access and harness evolving technologies. It is important to encourage universal access providers that deploy these low cost technologies and facilitate shared use of wireless equipment, networks and facilities for example at multi-purpose community centres, university, schools, hospitals and post offices.





My self Prakash


No comments: